MENU
 

PRE TAX NTA |$3.76

Value as at close of business on 17 January 2024

Is anyone brave or stupid enough to bet against America?

The media is accused of having many biases and one which we have to come clean on is active investment management. Readers want ideas, opinions, trades and stock tips and it is active fund managers, not passive funds, that possess them.

The data, however, is less kind. A Morningstar active versus passive barometer published last week showed that most funds managing Australian large cap and global stocks could not beat passive funds over 10 years. Small caps are the exception where active funds succeed.

Wall Street legend Howard Marks told the Sohn event that US exceptionalism would endure. Picture: Ben Searcy


The lure of the stock picker was on full display in Adelaide last week as the Sohn Hearts & Minds philanthropic investment conference rolled into town.

The event, which involves a dozen fund managers pitching their best stock tips, is as close to a live sporting event as the investment industry gets.

Ironically, one of the more compelling tips was to buy a struggling asset manager. Chris Kourtis from Ellerston’s big idea was to buy Perpetual, the once proud investment firm that has come unstuck due to a capital-destroying spending spree.

The pitch from Kourtis is that once Perpetual offloads its wealth management and corporate trust units, shareholders will be paid about $1 billion. They will also own shares in a global funds management firm with $212 billion of assets that generates around $230 million of earnings.

Kourtis is factoring in an earnings decline of about 10 per cent if the trend of client outflows persists. But even then, the current share price implies an enterprise valuation of just four times earnings – around a 70 per cent discount to its peer group.

Perpetual’s problem isn’t performance. Most of the funds it owns are actually delivering returns about their benchmark. Rather, it’s a combination of industry trends, an overburdened balance sheet, and poor cost control that has led the market to abandon it.

The problems at Perpetual were a topic of chatter in the high-end pubs of Hobart when the city hosted the 2022 stock-picking festival. Back then, ASX-listed hedge fund manager Regal made an audacious bid for Perpetual that was rejected by the board on valuation grounds, and killed off by a court ruling.

Funds management history is being rewritten, but not by Perpetual. Once again, the common force is Regal, and this time, the target is Platinum Asset Management.

Platinum’s board in September rejected an offer tabled by Regal. We are now waiting for an improved deal and there is substantial speculation that there are other parties running the ruler over Platinum. As yet, no one else has shown their hand.

Platinum’s issues are well documented and long-standing. The firm was founded in 1994 by Kerr Neilson, a funds management Hall of Famer. The global equities firm was a pioneer in convincing Australians to invest more of their savings internationally. But its clients are deserting it, meaning earnings and funds under management are in decline and its share price has followed.‍

Platinum founder Kerr Neilson casts his ballot at the Platinum annual general meeting in Sydney last week.


The heart of its problem has been performance. Platinum was well positioned after the 2008 global financial crisis (and could have done even better if it had not closed out short bets against US banks at the worst time).

It piled into cheap US stocks in the aftermath. But for the last decade or so, its value-investing philosophy has enticed it to own more stocks in China and Europe.

Put simply, it has bet against America, and that has not paid off. The last decade has been defined as a period of American exceptionalism as its economy has outpaced all other markets.

Barclays economist Ajay Rajadhyaksha points out that more than 15 years ago, the European and US economies were roughly equal in size. Now America is double the size and leads the way in energy, finance and technology.

That’s been amplified in the stockmarket where US tech giants have powered gains.

And in the 16 years since the global financial crisis, the combined share of the global market index of Europe and Japan has halved from 39 to 20 per cent while the US has grown to account for two-thirds.‍

Passive beating active
The trend has accelerated this year. In the first six months of the year, the US market accounted for 75 per cent of global stockmarket returns, according to Aubrey Capital Management. Chipmaker Nvidia was half the market return.

The Morningstar report reveals the woes of active managers are most profound in global strategies offered in Australia. Only 22 per cent of managers have beaten passive funds over five years, and 24 per cent over 10 years.

The main reason for this is the dominance of US stocks, and in particular the so-called magnificent seven technology stocks.

Platinum chief executive Jeff Peters explained to shareholders why it trailed the global shares benchmark: an overweight bet on Chinese stocks, which despite a recent rally have had a shocking time; an underweight bet on US tech; and holding too much cash in a rising market. (Platinum has tried to argue it should be judged against a more diversified equal-weight index.)

The question is what to do now. Platinum’s new director and former portfolio manager, James Simpson, told shareholders that the firm’s turnaround was largely about fixing performance.‍

Double down or quit?
But Platinum’s analysts to their credit and their detriment have obeyed their value-driven process, which he described “as pure as the driven snow”.

What is needed, he says, is more flexibility. That seems to translate to investing in a way that is more sensitive to what’s in the benchmark Platinum is trying to beat. Surely that means putting more US stocks into the portfolio?

Events would suggest that is logical. Donald Trump’s election victory has elicited a sense of euphoria among global investors that the US economy and its sharemarket will power further ahead. Meanwhile, his stance on trade suggests more of that growth will come at the expense of other markets.

The sentiment was captured by hedge fund manager Bill Ackman, who told his 2 million social media followers that the US business community “is giddy with excitement”.

“China’s economy is in trouble. Europe’s is a mess. The US has now become by far the best country for investment. Growth is about to explode.”

So, is it time for investors to double down on the US? Wall Street legend Howard Marks told the Sohn event that US exceptionalism would endure. But the catch is that it’s largely in the price. The market believes in the US story and that means valuations have become more stretched.

European and Chinese stocks by contrast are beaten up and in the bargain bin, ready for contrarians to climb in. And a handful of stocks pitched at Sohn suggested some are ready: among them were Chinese domestic equity plays Tencent Music and DiDi, a Spanish telco tower operator (Cellnex), and a European aircraft maker (Airbus) banking on Chinese growth.

It is counter consensus but could now be the time to walk back US stock bets? Platinum has thought so for a while, and been wrong. Arguably the biggest call global stock pickers, wealth managers and superannuation’s investment captains can make is whether to double down or quit on American exceptionalism

This article was originally posted by The Australian Financial Review here.

Licensed by Copyright Agency. You must not copy this work without permission.


Disclaimer: This material has been prepared by The Australian Financial Review, published on 17 November 2024. HM1 is not responsible for the content of linked websites or content prepared by third party. The inclusion of these links and third-party content does not in any way imply any form of endorsement by HM1 of the products or services provided by persons or organisations who are responsible for the linked websites and third-party content. This information is for general information only and does not consider the objectives, financial situation or needs of any person. Before making an investment decision, you should read the relevant disclosure document (if appropriate) and seek professional advice to determine whether the investment and information is suitable for you.

Recent Posts

Read the latest insights
A curated list of HM1 investor updates, portfolio news and other interesting articles.
Read More
Nine top stock picks to prepare your portfolio for 2025
Health care, ride-sharing, and the emerging world of YouTube entertainers are among the industries leading investors have picked for growth in 2025.
Resources fundies reveal top picks ahead of ‘stellar’ 2025
Some of Australia’s biggest resources funds are gearing up for a bumper start to the new year.
Qiao Ma: finding killer companies, surviving the GFC & why founders win
Qiao Ma, Portfolio Manager of the Munro Partners joins Owen Rask on The Australian Investors Podcast.
10 top fund managers reveal their long-term stock picks
With valuations stretched and geopolitical tensions high, the new year offers plenty of potholes for investors. 
 

Nine top stock picks to prepare your portfolio for 2025

Health care, ride-sharing, and the emerging world of YouTube entertainers are among the industries leading investors have picked for growth in 2025.

Read More
January 21st, 2025
 

Resources fundies reveal top picks ahead of ‘stellar’ 2025

Some of Australia’s biggest resources funds are gearing up for a bumper start to the new year.

Read More
January 6th, 2025
 

Qiao Ma: finding killer companies, surviving the GFC & why founders win

Qiao Ma, Portfolio Manager of the Munro Partners joins Owen Rask on The Australian Investors Podcast.

Read More
January 6th, 2025
 

10 top fund managers reveal their long-term stock picks

With valuations stretched and geopolitical tensions high, the new year offers plenty of potholes for investors. 

Read More
December 28th, 2024
 

Rikki Bannan – Don’t get caught up in momentum

Conference Fund Manager Rikki Bannan, Executive Director at IFM Investors, joins Equity Mates to discuss her standout 2023 stock pick, Telix, and explore what opportunities lie ahead.

Read More
December 19th, 2024
 

Professor Jane Butler: Sparking Hope for Spinal Cord Injuries

In this episode of the Hearts & Minds Podcast, we sit down with Professor Jane Butler to discuss her groundbreaking research into spinal cord injuries.

Read More
December 10th, 2024
 

Nick Griffin – The Nvidia story is not over

Nick Griffin, Founding Partner & Chief Investment Officer of Munro Partners joined the Equity Mates podcast in their Summer Series.

Read More
December 9th, 2024
 

HM1 CEO Succession

Hearts and Minds Investments Limited advises that Paul Rayson intends to retire from the position of Chief Executive Officer, effective 19 February 2025.

Read More
December 5th, 2024
 

Trump unifies top investors in decade-long bullish outlook for US

Nick Moakes, CIO of the $72 billion Wellcome Trust, told the conference that too many investors were banking on a return to the ultra-low interest rates that prevailed over the past decade.

Read More
November 20th, 2024
 

These rock-star stock picks could get markets talking next year

Eleven rock stars of international and local funds management took to stage – each tasked with picking and pitching one company whose shares will take off over the next year.

Read More
November 18th, 2024
 

Is anyone brave or stupid enough to bet against America?

Stock pickers have been punished for betting against the US. The choice between consensus and contrarianism on American exceptionalism is now harder than ever.

Read More
November 17th, 2024
 

Sohn: NYSE-listed Estee Lauder’s Northcape Capital pick

Northcape Capital’s Fleur Wright this gives a rare opportunity to buy a high quality company at an attractive price.

Read More
November 15th, 2024
 

Sohn ASX stock pick: Ellerston Capital’s Chris Kourtis backs Perpetual

Chris Kourtis has put his biggest bet on embattled Perpetual – picking one of the most hated stocks on the ASX – that he believes will soon be the ‘cheapest listed asset manager of scale in the universe’.

Read More
November 15th, 2024
 

AI start-ups a threat to incumbent big companies

Paul Bassat predicts emerging artificial intelligence companies will disrupt sectors and overtake established incumbent companies just as rapidly as the seismic shifts that took place when the internet emerged in the mid-1990s.

Read More
November 15th, 2024
 

Howard Marks and Sohn’s big stars reveal seven rules for investing

Among the stock picks and stunts at the Sohh Hearts & Minds event, Howard Marks and Nick Moakes provided investors with long-term rules for playing markets.

Read More
November 15th, 2024
 

Sohn investors position for bullish but bumpy Trump ride

Australia and the rest of the world must adjust to a new Trump presidency that will deliver an expected bull market but also disruption, with the leader in waiting prepared to “create pain” to get his way.

Read More
November 15th, 2024
 

Sohn stock picker experts name best shares to invest in for year ahead

‍Don’t overlook down and out silver miners, legacy skincare brands ready for a revival and a big financial company suffering from a severe case of shareholder wealth destruction.

Read More
November 15th, 2024
 

Eleven stock tips from Sohn to get you through 2025

“There’s no finer place for the finance festival than in the festival city,” said Matthew Grounds. He, along with fellow Barrenjoey co-executive chairman Guy Fowler and investor Gary Weiss, is one of Sohn’s driving forces.

Read More
November 15th, 2024
 

Sohn Hearts & Minds Investments fund targets $1.5bn valuation

‍Hearts & Minds Investments chair Chris Cuffe is hoping for HM1 to grow to more than $1.5bn in the next five years.

Read More
November 14th, 2024
 

Galaxy Digital CEO Mike Novogratz believes bitcoin will hit $US100k

Bitcoin’s bounce to record highs in recent days is only the beginning of a fresh surge higher for cryptocurrency, says US billionaire Mike Novogratz.

Read More
November 9th, 2024
 

Why this New York hedge fund manager sees opportunity in European stocks

Influential New York-hedge fund manager Ricky Sandler will turn to Europe for his next stock pick.

Read More
November 6th, 2024
 

Antipodes’ Ross says short-term wealth hinges on US election

The portfolio manager says defensive stocks pose a bigger risk than the magnificent seven for investors that are overexposed to the American sharemarket.

Read More
November 5th, 2024
 

Concentration risk key for investors: Antipodes Partners’ Vihari Ross

The concentration risk in global stock indexes that has built up during the strong rise over the past year must now be a key consideration for global investors, according to Vihari Ross.

Read More
November 5th, 2024
 

The fundie betting big on China – with help from AI

Mr Mehta is sticking to his well-worn strategy: he’s hunting for companies across Asia that aren’t battling intense competition and have management teams focused on costs, cash generation and high payouts to shareholders.

Read More
November 5th, 2024
 

Why this fundie wants you to ‘wince’ at his stock picks

When fund managers come to pitch their favourite stock at the annual Sohn Hearts & Minds conference, there are two ways they can go: they can play it safe, or they can take a risk and shock the room.

 

Read More
October 29th, 2024
 

IFM Investors’ Rikki Bannan backs small cap investments to rebound after mixed performance

IFM Investors executive director Rikki Bannan believes this year could be a good one to invest in some select small cap stocks.

Read More
October 27th, 2024
 

Meet the 2024 Conference Managers

Following a global search, the Conference Fund Manager Selection Committee is pleased to share eleven new managers for 2024. 

Read More
October 22nd, 2024
 

Chris Kourtis is on a winning streak. Here’s his next ASX pick

Chris Kourtis of Ellerston Capital thinks he’s found another winner and thinks it’s the last chance to have a bite at the cherry before the strategy plays out.

Read More
October 21st, 2024
 

Why Ellerston Capital’s Chris Kourtis plans to back a ‘hated’ stock

Chris Kourtis of Ellerston Capital plans to tip one of the “most hated” stocks in Australia when he presents at the 2024 Sohn Hearts & Minds Conference.

Read More
October 21st, 2024
 

Alex Pollak champions rewards of disruptive investment

Alex Pollak’s funds management company Loftus Peak rode the Nvidia wave and he is now looking at more opportunities in disruptive industry stocks.

Read More
October 14th, 2024